4AM Slice

Impulsively stopped here because I could smell it from the street, had fresh pepperoni slices finished right when we walked in and they were fantastic! Great undercarriage too!

I went out on a Friday night to meet a friend and finally decided to check out 4AM Slice after walking and driving past it countless times. I knew exactly what I was walking into—it is called 4AM Slice, after all. I went in around 10 p.m. and ordered pepperoni and sausage. The building itself is gorgeous—the architecture is truly stunning if you take a moment to look around. The decor fits the name perfectly: very Cleveland, very pizza-centric, and exactly the vibe you’d expect for a late-night slice spot. The person working was friendly, welcoming, and accommodating. It wasn’t busy at all, which made it a relaxed stop. The pizza was exactly what I expected: a slice of pizza. Not amazing, not terrible—just straightforward, no-frills pizza. I’m glad I checked it out and experienced the space.

All the pizza was great with great prices and the option to pick ready made slices. The Buffalo pizza was very good, not spicy, but perfect buttery Buffalo flavor. The staff (especially the, I think, owner) cares a lot and provides great service! We’ll definitely be back if we’re back in town!

Amazing pizza, no flop and perfect crunch. Could not have asked for a better NY style pizza. Not sure about the evening, could be a cool night hot spot. A+

Ordered a pizza while staying downtown. It was so good, definitely didn't expect the size and am still thinking about it after over eating because it was just that good. It's like pizza you see in cartoons.

4AM Slice is an absolute gem and easily the best pizza spot in the area! I’ve tried multiple places around here, and nothing comes close. Everything they make is homemade, and you can taste the quality in every bite. The pizza cheese is rich, high-quality, and melts perfectly, while the sauce has that authentic, flavorful taste that makes their pies stand out from the rest. I ordered the Pepperoni and the Home Garden Pizza, and both were phenomenal—fresh ingredients, perfect crust, and just the right amount of seasoning. Honestly, you can order anything on their menu because everything is delicious! The wings are next-level, too. They’re not your average wings—they’re big, meaty, and cooked just right. I highly recommend getting at least a dozen. I’ve had both the Buffalo and Garlic Parm flavors, and they were absolutely incredible. On top of that, the customer service is always friendly and professional, and their delivery is fast, which is perfect for those late-night cravings. They’re open late, so when other places shut down, 4AM Slice has your back! If you’re looking for amazing pizza, top-quality wings, and a place that truly cares about what they serve, support local and give 4AM Slice a try—you won’t regret it!

Great place! I stopped in and was pleasantly surprised! Got the buffalo chicken slice. Everything about it was great from the ingredients to the crust. The employee's were very friendly and helpful. I will definitely return.